• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your WyoNation.com experience today!

CFP Committee sells out

Wyo2dal

Wyo2dal

Well-known member
Ok so it has to be said, OSU getting into the Play Offs is all about $$$$ and has nothing to do with who played who. But now it begs the question who is the B12 going to go after to get to 12 teams?

This year has made it obvious a conference without a Championship game has no chance of ever making the top 4. B12 got flat out screwed by a committee that might as well have been paid off.

So who goes to the B12? Name your top 2 teams, It's coming and it has to happen.
 
Media on Twitter have made it clear....it's Boise and BYU is you want great programs, Cincinnati and Memphis if you want TV sets. Hate to say it, but I think TV power will remain the deciding factor in all expansion. Schools like Colorado State can just stop, it's never going to happen. $$$$ comes from markets, not stadiums.

I don't think it happens just yet. Big XII will wait to see if their proposal to waive the 12-team requirement for a title game is approved this upcoming summer.
 
J-Rod said:
Media on Twitter have made it clear....it's Boise and BYU is you want great programs, Cincinnati and Memphis if you want TV sets. Hate to say it, but I think TV power will remain the deciding factor in all expansion. Schools like Colorado State can just stop, it's never going to happen. $$$$ comes from markets, not stadiums.

I don't think it happens just yet. Big XII will wait to see if their proposal to waive the 12-team requirement for a title game is approved this upcoming summer.
Click to expand...

I don't think it will get waived and they will have to pickup two more teams.
 
Wyo2dal said:
I don't think it will get waived and they will have to pickup two more teams.
Click to expand...
I agree, I'm only pointing that out so when we inevitably hear rumors this spring, we know it's bullshit cause they won't pull any trigger until July at the very earliest.
 
J-Rod said:
Wyo2dal said:
I don't think it will get waived and they will have to pickup two more teams.
Click to expand...
I agree, I'm only pointing that out so when we inevitably hear rumors this spring, we know it's bullshit cause they won't pull any trigger until July at the very earliest.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't be surprised to see BYU involved in that at all, But honestly I also wouldn't be surprised to see BSU/SDSU names coming into play mainly because of that Big East buddy pact and for the B12 to show interest in Idaho they would need a trael partner for Boise.
 
Wyo2dal said:
I wouldn't be surprised to see BYU involved in that at all, But honestly I also wouldn't be surprised to see BSU/SDSU names coming into play mainly because of that Big East buddy pact and for the B12 to show interest in Idaho they would need a trael partner for Boise.
Click to expand...
Agreed. Comes down to what the Big XII wants to emphasize...increasing overall football power in the conference to compete with the SEC (Boise/BYU)....or is this still about raking in more $$$$ (Cincy/Memphis) and nothing else?
 
It'll be all about money. The schools in the Big 12 don't want to expand because they'll lose money. If they have to expand they'll take the biggest markets available to limit the amount of money they lose.
 
I wonder if Utah in the PAC will screw byu. The SLC market is good but if you split it, then it is just average. I remember T. Boone dead set against byu. Not that he is an AD or anything, but it would surprise me if he was the only one with that opinion.

I too think they expand, but if it were OU and Texas rather than TCU and Baylor, the selection might have been different.
 
http://m.espn.go.com/ncf/story?storyId=11993892" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Interesting comments by Big 12 commish.
 
Alot of people are thinking a western expansion eg byu and Boise state. In reality I think the American Conference UCF and maybe Louisville? I think they would want a team in Florida and I think that some of the Eastern schools could be taken from power conferences.
 
B12 commented a while ago they weren't interested in expanding west only east which would make sense as the travel for west coast addition would suck.
 
Wyo2dal said:
Ok so it has to be said, OSU getting into the Play Offs is all about $$$$ and has nothing to do with who played who. But now it begs the question who is the B12 going to go after to get to 12 teams?

This year has made it obvious a conference without a Championship game has no chance of ever making the top 4. B12 got flat out screwed by a committee that might as well have been paid off.

So who goes to the B12? Name your top 2 teams, It's coming and it has to happen.
Click to expand...

I thought it was strange that Ohio State was accepted over TCU or Baylor. On some level you can't just look at big wins but also look at bad losses.

TCU's only loss was to a one loss Baylor team
Baylors only loss was to a five loss west virginia
Ohio States only loss was to a six loss Virginia Tech.

of the three teams TCU had the "best" loss and Ohio State had the worst. Seems interesting to say the least. I think that is what bothers me the most about this playoff committee. Everyone has such short term memory and doesn't take into account the full body of work.
 
I think that is what bothers me the most about this playoff committee. Everyone has such short term memory and doesn't take into account the full body of work.
Click to expand...

Oh, goodness, that committee is hyper-aware of that.
 
Spindoctor posted this on Facebook earlier.. read this over, then tell me the three teams you'd have in the playoff.

Team #1: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 113.
Team #2: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 120.
Team #3: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 2 scores, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 163.
Team #4: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 50 team at home by 2 scores, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 86.
Team #5: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team at home by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 99.
 
MrTitleist said:
Spindoctor posted this on Facebook earlier.. read this over, then tell me the three teams you'd have in the playoff.

Team #1: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 113.
Team #2: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 120.
Team #3: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team on road by 2 scores, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 163.
Team #4: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 50 team at home by 2 scores, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 86.
Team #5: Conference Champion, only one loss to top 30 team at home by 1 score, avg Sagarin ranking of OOC opponents = 99.
Click to expand...

I couldn't fairly pick 3 teams with that small amount of data, I need to know who lost to who and how many wins/losses those teams had not to mention would need to know about performance of the games. These are all things the committee needed to take under advisement and it would appear they didn't watch over half the games this year.
 
That's not the point of this exercise. Of those five teams, which three do you pick for the playoff given the data.
 
MrTitleist said:
That's not the point of this exercise. Of those five teams, which three do you pick for the playoff given the data.
Click to expand...

Find someone else I'm anti BCS and your just asking me to play along with what i'm against as those ratings listed are probably Baylor/TCU/OSU haha.

99/113/120, 86 is a good rating but getting beat by 2 scores at home by a top 50 team would really jack the weightings up.
 
It's a fair method though. This is the only way to truly take out true bias based on school name and conference affiliation. While some might say that TCU and Baylor got hosed, others will say the Big XII is overrated. Too much personal bias involved in these which is why I'd like to see A 12-team bracket. Every conference champ gets in, 2 at large spots, if you are #13, tough shit, should have won your conference.
 
I said this on another board, but TCU or Baylor would be in if they had the money behind them like Texas or Oklahoma. This 4 team system is a scam just like the BCS system has been for years.
 
Or if their SOS was better than hot garbage and not co-champions. TCUs only loss was to a top 10 Baylor team on the road. Baylor's loss was to unranked West Virginia.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top