NowherePoke
Well-known member
ItSucksToBeACSURam said:McClain tenure wasnt awful here. I don't get the hate for him.307bball said:ItSucksToBeACSURam said:I want to ensure I'm following you.... You would rather have this team, a work in progress with a lot of growing and learning to do, over past teams, say the 01-02 team who was loaded and maybe the best top to bottom team we've had in the last three decades.... Did I read that right?307bball said:My whole intent in bringing up the comparison to the 02 team is to highlight where we are talent-wise compared to the heights that have been achieved in the past. That team was loaded...McClain deserves a lot of credit for the guys he got in there and the ego's he had to mesh but you did not need to be a master tactition to roll the ball out and beat people when you have a better man for man team than the opponent on a nightly basis. That has always been the exception, not the rule, at WYO. Judged on a sum-of-it's parts basis Shyatt's teams have had, in my opinion, less than stellar personell....what Shyatt brings is the ability to take hard working, good attitude guys and create something that is greater than the sum of it's parts. In this aspect he feels like a great coach...sprinkle in a little talent and .. voila .. you get runs like last year's team was on pre and post mono episode. However...however....he may not be getting it done recruiting-wise. Ask yourself "what if Coach K was coaching this team?..Would we be leading the conference?" My answer is not a chance. The guy's on last years team bought in to Larry's system and, anchored by two very good collegiate big men, made some noise. I want to see Larry coach these guys up...the losses right now are frustrating but to people who know what to watch for it's obvious they get it...they know what to do but can't quite execute consistently. I'll take this years poor results with less than great talent over some of the more talented squads of the past that had no cohesion and little discipline.
Heh...not quite...results like that 01-02 team had are obviously my preference...what i'm saying is that I can watch this team struggle to find itself and enjoy it more than teams past that had more talent but were not led (coached) appropriately. If my choice is between this team or the 01-02 team than its a no brainer...the better question is Shyatt's tenure or McClain's tenure?
- He he finished 1st in the conference regular season twice.
- He finished 4th or better 4 times.
- He took us to 1 NCAA appearance with a record of 1-1
- He took us to 3 NIT appearances with a record of 2-3
- He never appeared in any other post season tourney such as CBI
- He had a .557 overall winning percentage at UW and .507 in conference.
Shyatts line in comparison:
- Has never finished higher than 4th in the regular season
- Has taken us to 1 NCAA appearance with a record of 0-1
- Took us to 1 NIT appearance with a record of 0-1
- He has taken us to 3 CBI tournaments with a record of 4-3
- He has a .608 overall winning percentage at UW and .473 in conference
McClain got ran out of town like he was a murderer but his overall performance here wasn't any worse than Shyatts. Shyatt slunk out of town the first time (after using us as a yearly stepping stone), sued the university, and is welcomed back and heralded like he's the second coming of Coach K while doing nothing more spectacular than McClain in his time here. Sometimes I don't understand Wyoming fans
I am hardly a Shyatt cheerleader, but this is very misleading. All of the accolades accomplished by McClain occurred in his first 5 seasons, his last 4 seasons we was 23-37 in MWC play. The hate towards McClain is because he squandered a golden opportunity. The Pokes were MWC champions, winners of a NCAA tourney game, and playing in front of average crowds of 10k and all the momentum was squandered away. While the exact reasons can be debated, you take that decline in results along with the following:
1. Recruiting - McClain inherited McMillan, McFall, Blakes, Jones, Ugo, and Davis. Those were the core of his first few teams including the 00-01 MWC co-championship team. The only other notable pieces were Bailey who fell into his lap (read Bailey's own comments regarding his recruitment, he was not a priority for McClain) and Uche who was, correctly or not, viewed as someone we landed because we already had Ugo. Once those players departed, McClain was unable to build a consistently successful roster with his own recruits. I do give McClain more credit than some as the 01-02 team was really his. He recruited most of the players, even if he got lucky with Bailey/Uche, and more importantly he coached them through their entire careers. Bailey, Davis, Uche, etc. developed as players under McClain and he deserves credit for that.
2. Program Perception - Due to a number of factors including low APR, off the court problems, and the fight at New Mexico, the program was viewed as being filled with troublemakers and poor students. It wasn't necessarily a fair characterization, but it wasn't without merit either. This didn't help McClain when things went south.
Personally, McClain was a better coach than I gave him credit for at the time and I do respect Steve.
Having said that, when evaluating Shyatt you have to look at the other factors. In both cases, he took over the UW program when it was in bad shape. First after Joby Wrong and then after Schroyer. He set the table for McClain, while never having had the luxury of seeing the favor returned.