He was let go because he was a holdover coach from a previous staff.
Correct. He was the OC under Mel Tucker who was fired. Besides Tucker being fired a couple of assistants were implicated in cheating. Johnson was not named as any part of that illicit activity but potentially benefited from the recruiting activities.
A closer look at Jay’s stints as an experienced coach the past 10 years. Here are his stats for his last 8 seasons as the OC. It’s the national rankings for:
YEAR - TotOFF/TotPass - SCORING/Points
2025 - 118/113 - 129/16.8
2024 - 119/107 - 123/19.3
2023 - 128/98 - 131/15.9
2022 - 97/58 - 91/24.4
2021 - 43/49 - 39/31.8
2020 - 109/54 - 116/18.0
2019 - 82/61 - 100/23.5
2016 - 107/111 - 63/29.3
Average- 100/81.5 - 99/22.38
Team W-L at OC stints:
7-16 Wyo
22-22 MSU
5-7 CU
9-4 MN
43-49 .467
Scoring:
2 years 29.3 or higher
2 years 23.5-24.4
4 years 19.3 or less
Not the worst but definitely the bottom 1/3 of the FBS. As for his one exceptional year in 2021 even Bohl was an offensive guru in 2016 and not close there after. The biggest indicator is 6 of 8 seasons are under 25 points in average scoring. That means the team better be pretty stout with the defense.
Wyoming is at 19.6 ppg allowed but not good enough to win games this year which is the season Sawful demoted Jay Johnson from his position. I give Johnson credit for this year because it was his setup.
Here’s what Sawful said he wanted from the offense in December 2023:
"I have a simple philosophy … explosive players make explosive plays," Sawvel said at his introductory press conference in December after being promoted to replace Craig Bohl. "What we've got to do is make sure we get explosive players the ball, we've got to recruit and obtain and retain explosive players and then we've got to make it to where those guys can play really fast."
Johnson was a OC before he got here and was a long time QB coach, two things that I have not seen in a OC in a while at UW.
If Johnson is a nice get because he has coached QB’s along with having one really good OC year, he definitely didn’t convince Sawful the offense was not going to produce in 2024 or 2025. It kind of shows in his pattern of weaker offenses. Maybe he didn’t realize he really didn’t have the players needed to work with but told Sawful he was ready to let the offense explode!