I think there is some confusion about what is meant by being disappointed. If the metric is just as simple as "am I happy or unhappy with the program"...then I think a lot of people's answer during Bohl's tenure would be yes...if you just have to choose between those two options. That is different than being satisfied though. "Happy with the program" seems to mean winning home games, no scandals, and beating CSU a lot. Most fans seem "happy" with those outcomes while at the same time being disappointed that the top of the conference is always out of reach.
In general, I think it's really hard to do what Bohl did ... meaning that to only barely be .500 in conference for the last 8 years while still being successful at those metrics that keep fans happy is no small feat. IMO, if coach Turkey Club's program can't at least maintain the level of success that Bohl's program had, it only makes my argument stronger that winning (at something near the level of BSU) at the University of Wyoming is constrained by factors outside of the control of the man running the football program. the only way to disprove this is if coach BLT or some future coach actually pulls off a run of successful years vying for and winning conference titles. The pace at which Wyoming goes through coaches means that by 2050 we might have 4 to 6 more coaches that we have gone through.....I wish they would give guys two years (maybe 3) to win or appear in a title game. With that sort of policy, we at least get the most bites at the apple. You could make some version of that for the Athletic Director as well....