OrediggerPoke said:
CowboyNV said:
pokefanchaz7 said:
This just in... Josh Allen playing in bowl game
So, Nostradamus, how long does he stay in? You think he trots in the first series, throws one ball, comes to the sidelines and says he's just not 100%.....I guess that is still playing, right? Unfortunately, as abysmal as the offense has been this year, I'm not convinced it makes any difference who is QB. In the end, it is still Vigen calling the horseshit plays, an O line that isn't blocking, a bunch of receivers who can't catch, and Allen (or Smith) running for his life as he is getting beaten like a drum. The defense will have to win this one, as the O will not be much help. I will go out on a limb and say it is Directional Michigan by 10.
Wow, Mr. Negative, are you sure being a Pokes fan is good for your health?
Your thought that Allen will go out and throw one ball lacks any basis in rationality. Doing so would raise a bunch of red flags and kill his draft stock. Have you watched Allen play, ever?? The dude is a competitor and, if he is playing, I guarantee he is playing to win. Not some dog and pony show.
I'm sorry that your view of the Pokes lacks any optimism. But I will tell you that Josh Allen certainly can lead the team to a win, even given the struggles of this offensive unit. I am looking forward to the game and Allen leading the Pokes to one final win before he heads off to the NFL.
I'm not being negative, nor pessimistic, simply a realist after all of these years. I do make a bit of extra spending money betting on games, so I do watch and pay attention to things. I'm not sure what inspires all of the confidence in Josh. While he certainly has all of the physical skills necessary to play at the next level, I don't think his mental game has quite caught up to his physical game. I think it will, but it simply has not at this point. Let's look at his season:
Iowa - 8-15 for 125 yds. with 3 td's and 1 int. Not a bad line, but not good enough to win against a good team.
GWU - 22-32 for 328 yds with 2 td's. One of his best performances, but it came against a glorified high school team.
Oregon - 9-24 for 64 yds and 1 int. Enough said.
Hawaii - 9-19 for 92 yds and 1 td. I wouldn't call this a future NFL Hall of Famer performance, but thanks to the D the Pokes did win the game.
Tx. St. - 14-24 for 219 yds and 3 tds. Pretty workmanlike performance against a fairly bad team. He looked OK, but again it was against sub par competition.
UT St. - 18-26 for 208 yds with 1 td and 1 int. Again, I would grade this performance a B- or C+. Good enough to get the win, but not good enough to make me go "Wow!"
BSU - 12-27 for 131 yds with 1 td and 2 int's. He faced a good defense and it showed in this game. This game (along with Oregon) illustrated how bad the O line, receivers, backs, and Vigen are.
NMU - 16-28 for 234 yds with 4 tds. I actually think this was his best game of the year to date, and really thought that things were about to turn the corner for him.
CSU - 10-20 for 138 yds with 0 tds and 0 int's. While I was thrilled to get the win, another decent defense exposed the offensive woes of this team.
AFA - 8-11 for 70 yds and 1 td. I thought Allen looked like this was going to be one of his better performances, but then came the injury and we all know the rest of the story.
So, looking at these numbers without brown and gold glasses on, Allen, despite his numerous physical skills and leadership, could not make the blocks, run the routes, catch the ball, or come up with a game plan. Those deficiencies by others cause him to make bad decisions trying to do too much. He is limited by those around him and instead of elevating them to the next level (like last year), this bunch has failed to respond 100% of the time.
I know what a shoulder separation feels like (I had to have 3 surgeries to repair mine). I also know that if Josh feels any pain at all he will pull himself out of there. So, I simply do not see him playing the whole game, especially if the line allows him to take beatings like he took all year. If you optimists look at this as negative or cynical, then that's your opinion (you certainly are entitled to it). But I also look at this as a bettor, and I just don't see the Pokes, with or without Allen) pulling this one out.