seattlecowboy said:
Some of you guys need to look at this more from a realistic perspective.
In Bouchers case he grew up in Canada and then went to New Mexico for one year. His stats were okay but they weren't eye popping enough while at the New Mexico JC that would have made you just automatically want to recruit him over Justin James, Conway, Naughton or Moemeka at the time. Then he comes to a Wyoming JC for one year and that is when he blows up. By the time he blows up Wyoming didn't have any scholarships open and people started to notice him halfway through the season.
First off he doesn't have a connection to Wyoming other then the one year here. Secondly what is Shyatt and staff supposed to do at that point? Recruit him hard and secretly hope someone leaves the team? The fact someone left the team the last month of the year wasn't something that was expected and by that time it was too late to try and hope to get Boucher when he had multiple offers starting to come in from the big 5 conference schools.
Then same goes with this Williams kid at Gillette. I would say since he had been in Wyoming two years instead of one he would be more of someone that you might have looked at. He had decent stats as well after his freshman year. Again though were his stats eye popping enough for us to go after him more than another player at the time with the one scholarship we had open? Williams blew up again his 2nd year after we had filled the scholarship and now we are thinking we are going to get him because someone left our team the last month of the year to open another scholarship up and this kid is from London and is getting big time offers now?
It would be one thing if we had scholarships available to recruit these guys but at the time we didn't have any open. Shyatt seems to be a class act and tries to take care of the kids he recruits. I don't really see him going behind someone's back and trying to recruit these other kids hard and secretly hoping someone on the team quits.
I agree we need to have good connections with all of the JC coaches in the state of Wyoming and if they see something from a kid early on then we need to be looking at them before all of the scholarships are filled but I can't fault the staff in either of these situations the way they played out. Just my opinion.
While I agree with your basic premise (and also would point out that even if you are on top of a kids recruitment it doesn't mean you are going to land them when they are a high level recruit, ask Montana St.), there are a couple of items that should be noted:
1. While nothing was publicly announced, Tyrell Williams was no longer sitting on the sidelines or actively involved with the team from what we could tell after about the Christmas break. I would guess the coaching staff knew very well that he would be gone by January of 2015. I am not necessarily saying they should have been expected to land Boucher. USU was on him before then and it did them exactly zero good when Oregon and other high majors got involved. However, they did have the opportunity to get involved with JC big men in general and they didn't do it, resulting in signing Hayden Dalton. While Dalton works hard, it's not an exaggeration to say that if we had filled the PF spot this year with an average level MWC player (say Cullen Russo, who signed with Fresno, or Grandy Glaze who signed with GCU) we would be a top half MWC team. We were very competitive, but got destroyed on the glass and in the paint.
2. In terms of Kavell Bigby-Williams, he was known as an impact recruit really from the moment he started at Gillette. While maybe it wasn't known that he would end up a Texas level recruit, he was obviously at least a MWC caliber prospect from the very beginning. We did have a scholarship open for the Class of 2016 and used it on Austin Mueller. We also attempted to sign a big man, Irshad Hunte, who was not able to sign. IOW, I don't buy the argument that we didn't have a scholarship available.
Of course, it's possible we tried to recruit Bigby-Williams and were basically told not to bother. I don't know.