@ SJSU

[OrediggerPoke]

It was on third down so that if there was a bad snap or holder dropped the ball, you can just cover it up and get another attempt at the kick.

There are a lot of times I’ve been perplexed by Sawvel’s decision making, but this is not one of them. In my opinion, this is the exactly right call. I’m surprised it is getting as much attention as it has.

Agree.

 

[LanderPoke]

It was on third down so that if there was a bad snap or holder dropped the ball, you can just cover it up and get another attempt at the kick.

There are a lot of times I’ve been perplexed by Sawvel’s decision making, but this is not one of them. In my opinion, this is the exactly right call. I’m surprised it is getting as much attention as it has.

Why not just run it one yard and not even bother with a kick?

 

[TheRealUW]

Why not just run it one yard and not even bother with a kick?

We had already been stuffed on the goal line earlier in the game. We’ve also made a number of boneheaded plays in the red zone over the season (interceptions, sacks for huge yardage losses) and fumbles by our RB’s have also been a problem.

Contrast that with Sandvik who has been super solid this year and I think Sandvik was the safer option.

If it’s regulation time, you obviously go for the TD there. With it being OT and needing any number of points to win, you pick the easiest option to get those points. For some teams that might be a run or QB sneak for the TD. For us, it is definitely the FG.

 

[phxpoke]

Our kicker is money as well. I don’t believe he has missed a kick all season.

 

[OrediggerPoke]

Why not just run it one yard and not even bother with a kick?

Have you seen the offense? Remember what happened on the 1 yard line at NDSU? Remember what happened at the 1 yard line last year against Air Force? Kicking the ball had a much higher percentage of success . It was literally shorter than an extra point.

This is actually the first time I can say that the coaching staff made a wise decision. It took 3 years but we got there.

 

[laxwyo]

Better than getting clowned for getting stuffed at the 1 yard line

But it was only 3rd down, right?

 

[laxwyo]

Have you seen the offense? Remember what happened on the 1 yard line at NDSU? Remember what happened at the 1 yard line last year against Air Force? Kicking the ball had a much higher percentage of success . It was literally shorter than an extra point.

This is actually the first time I can say that the coaching staff made a wise decision. It took 3 years but we got there.

I was actually more surprised we got it to the 1. A lot of the time teams barely gain yards after the other teams fails to score. Have we had fumbles on the 1? I know we’ve sucked pounding it into the end zone but but I’d think running ball and then kicking on 4th down technically has the highest odds of winning.

 

[LanderPoke]

I was actually more surprised we got it to the 1. A lot of the time teams barely gain yards after the other teams fails to score. Have we had fumbles on the 1? I know we’ve sucked pounding it into the end zone but but I’d think running ball and then kicking on 4th down technically has the highest odds of winning.

Exactly. I would think this by far maximizes your chances of winning. Even if you lose 10 yards on 3rd down from the 1, the resulting fg attempt is like statistically the same as from the one yard line or whatever it was.

 

[TheRealUW]

Exactly. I would think this by far maximizes your chances of winning. Even if you lose 10 yards in 3rd down from the 1, the resulting fg attempt is like statistically the same as from the one yard line or whatever it was.

But then you only have one chance at the kick. If it’s a bad snap/hold, then there is a pretty good chance the game continues into the second overtime period.

If there is a bad/snap hold on third down, the kicking team can simply concentrate on recovering the ball and they get another chance to kick the winning the field goal on 4th down.

I’m certainly not saying every team should kick a FG on third down in that scenario. If you are confident in your offense or have an unreliable kicker, the best bet is to line up and try to score a TD on 2nd or 3rd down. But we are the exact opposite. We have an anemic offense and an offense that is prone to make mistakes. On the other hand, we have had a pretty damn good FG unit this year. For us, it was the right call to put that game into the hands of the FG unit.