McPeachy said:
Not to debate your last statement, but...
Legas didn't suit up against James Madison. His replacement - Hillstead, went 25/47 for 399 yards with 4 td's and 3 picks.
Mayden went 16/22 for 241 yards, with 1 td and 0 picks.
Both are far superior to the shit we saw Saturday. Just telling it like it is. I am not sure ANYONE IN THE COUNTRY matched the heroic 5/15 for 31 yards, and a pick 6...?
Oh...If the question is "whose stats would I want"...than it's a different answer...virtually any MW QB has better stats. Our offense does not produce passing yards or passing td's. Peasley is a part of that reason but IMO he's not the primary reason.
I'm not impressed greatly by Peasley....but i'm not impressed greatly by any of the MW qb's. I'm just looking at it from an eye-test sort of approach. Peas impressed a bit during the Tech game...was up and down (more up) during Portland St and then had an abysmall game against App St. That result is on him.... but not totally. The offense on Saturday was really, really bad at most everything....not just passing. Once they cleaned up the penalties, the run game actually sort of functioned but it was not rolling over the mountaineers.
Switching Peasley for Svoboda could provide a spark and a different wrinkle that might lead to better success....andy maybe Svoboda will only get better if he gets under center, but I don't see a glaring talent differential as of right now. I think the case for Svoboda would be that he has higher upside...but
I would counter with Bohl's iffy track record of making any signal-caller better.