joshvanklomp said:
LanderPoke said:
He very may be an impactful player in 2 years, but we need the help now. I think this why a lot on here are disappointed.
Why do we
need it?
This isn't a senior-laden team. It's a young team with only one senior. 12 of the 15 players on the roster are freshmen and sophomores. A mid-June signee wasn't going to make the difference between going to the NCAA tournament or not, anyways. This is going to be a year of development.
I think you just explained why we need it. It's not about the NCAA tourney, because you are right about that, it's about putting the best product possible on the floor and trying to maintain the momentum generated by last year's success.
Looking at next year's roster it's pretty clear that our weakness will be the frontcourt and as a result the Pokes will be picked 8th in the MWC in the preseason, most likely. Obviously that doesn't mean we finish that low, but I don't think it is out of the question that we could be below .500 in MWC play next year and really struggle on the glass. If we are going to sign a JC, why not sign one that can contribute over the next two years? Look at the guys that signed with other MWC schools: Torren Jones, Cullen Russo, Emmanual Omogbo, Kimani Jackson, etc. There were JC bigs out there that could have contributed next year and helped on the glass and they didn't sign with SDSU/UNLV or a P5 program. They signed with people like CSU and Fresno. Why can't we recruit at their level?
Dalton is a gamble on a prospect with length and a shooting touch that we are hoping will develop physically. In a vacuum, there is certainly nothing wrong with that as he could develop and be a contributor in a couple of years. However, for this particular roster we already have 4 underclassmen big men that are projects (although with Herndon going into his 3rd year in the program I would probably say he is past that point), so why add a 5th?
One of the primary aspects that sunk the Heath Schroyer regime, besides him being an a-hole, was roster composition (too many players with the same skill set in the same class, while other needs were completely ignored). Shyatt is a million times better at that, but the team is really in a hole in the front court for next year and I would have liked to see him do something about that this spring.