• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your WyoNation.com experience today!

Josh Doctson

OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.
You're right, he's worse. He can't even see a wide open receiver standing in the end zone when he's five yards from him.
 
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.

Today was probably his worst day, but this was the first game that I thought QB play cost us. We weren't going to be MSU or Oregon with anybody under center and Kirkegaard played more than well enough to win in Hawaii. Today however he was awful.
 
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.
 
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.
 
So, he was told to throw it away if the RB wasn't open? That's because he can't make progressions and sucks balls.

A lot better than me though but I'm not getting free education to play QB
 
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.
 
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

I agree. Common sense tells me that every receiver running a route is, at some point, a read...otherwise, why run the route?
 
well put there's ALWAYS another option, ALWAYS, hence why is there a defense on the field then, oh, only throw to that guy, IF HE'S OPEN, LOOK AROUND FOR A CHANGE, plays get busted all the time, heck, I liked it when Colby became mobile for a change it was somewhat effective, yards were gained
 
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.
It's obvious the play was designed to leak out a guy on the backside to throw to, but you're trying to tell me that was the only option on the play... That's a load of shit. There is no way the coaching staff is dumb enough to design such a stupid play. What was Colby supposed to do while the play developed... jerk himself off for a few seconds rather than looking at the guys running routes on that side of the field?
 
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

The Assumption was made by the OC that the Tight End would be covered so he told the QB not to look at him He did this ALL WEEK IN PRACTICE. The thought was that the RB would be open. It all goes back to a conservative offensive philosophy. I am telling you I know this for a fact as stupid as it sounds it wasn't Captian Kirk's fault. Now a great QB would have at least looked off the safety and in doing so would have seen Eric.
 
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

The Assumption was made by the OC that the Tight End would be covered so he told the QB not to look at him He did this ALL WEEK IN PRACTICE. The thought was that the RB would be open. It all goes back to a conservative offensive philosophy. I am telling you I know this for a fact as stupid as it sounds it wasn't Captian Kirk's fault. Now a great QB would have at least looked off the safety and in doing so would have seen Eric.


Fair enough, but at some point he should have been told or at least seen the TE as an Option.
 
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

The Assumption was made by the OC that the Tight End would be covered so he told the QB not to look at him He did this ALL WEEK IN PRACTICE. The thought was that the RB would be open. It all goes back to a conservative offensive philosophy. I am telling you I know this for a fact as stupid as it sounds it wasn't Captian Kirk's fault. Now a great QB would have at least looked off the safety and in doing so would have seen Eric.


Fair enough, but at some point he should have been told or at least seen the TE as an Option.

No arguments here.
 
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

The Assumption was made by the OC that the Tight End would be covered so he told the QB not to look at him He did this ALL WEEK IN PRACTICE. The thought was that the RB would be open. It all goes back to a conservative offensive philosophy. I am telling you I know this for a fact as stupid as it sounds it wasn't Captian Kirk's fault. Now a great QB would have at least looked off the safety and in doing so would have seen Eric.

This can't be true! Why would he tell him to ignore a receiver on the play? If you think he's going to be covered, why even send him out on a pattern?! "Whatever you do, don't throw it to the wide open guy."
 
SDPokeFan said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
Slow Hand said:
djm19 said:
OrediggerPoke said:
djm19 said:
And who would pass it to him?

The quarterback lining up behind center.

I was critical of Kirkegaard, but he is not as bad as people on here suggest.


Totally missed option 1 on his read. And it cost us the game. Seems like a nice enough guy... Just not fit to be a QB at fbs school.

Eric was not even a read, Colby was directed to throw it to the backside RB by the OC or throw it away if he isn't open. That is why he didn't even look at Eric because he wasn't supposed to. Now, had he seen him and thrown it to him it probably would have been all right with the OC.

Honestly, I don't know if I buy this. Where was Nzeocha running to then? if he wasn't a read at all...was he running to the bathroom? Was he supposed to make chicken noises and distract the defense?

Either way, if he wasn't "Option A" then he was AN option at some point. To think a coach told him "If the RB is covered and the TE is open, just throw that sumb#tch into the crowd..." is, well, asinine.

Maybe the OC told him to throw it away if no one was open meant, AFTER ALL YOUR READS, throw it away. Very very rarely is there ever one option on a roll out like that.

Plain and simple, he missed a WIDE open player he should have known was going to be over that way.

The Assumption was made by the OC that the Tight End would be covered so he told the QB not to look at him He did this ALL WEEK IN PRACTICE. The thought was that the RB would be open. It all goes back to a conservative offensive philosophy. I am telling you I know this for a fact as stupid as it sounds it wasn't Captian Kirk's fault. Now a great QB would have at least looked off the safety and in doing so would have seen Eric.

This can't be true! Why would he tell him to ignore a receiver on the play? If you think he's going to be covered, why even send him out on a pattern?! "Whatever you do, don't throw it to the wide open guy."

If this is true, then the coaches are dumbing down the offense to an all time low. Seriously, tell the quarterback to look for your primary receiver and if he's covered, then just chuck it out of bounds. If that really is the case, then it speaks volumes to the talent level on the O-line (only a second or two to get the pass away), the receivers (unable to get separation at the line and get open), and the quarterback (no ability to go through his progressions if his first option is covered). Shit, even the peewee football teams have more than one option on a pass play. This isn't conservative, it's pitiful if it is in fact true.
 
Back
Top