ItSucksToBeACSURam said:
FarmerPoke said:
bladerunnr said:
Wyolie Coyote said:
davidwyo said:
This will be a hated post for sure, but here goes: Edwards has done a great job his first year. Nobody was giving him or this team any shot to look competitive. Everyone on this forum can attest that Wyoming has a chance in every game. I do love the up tempo offense and I think the defense is great with the old Shyatt players. Edwards big test is the next couple games and the MW Tourney. That will let us all know if he can really coach and deliver when it counts or on the big stage, just win.
And yes, I'm bi-polar, where is that Xanax?
Media projected us to be 10th. We will finish either 8th or 9th. I don't see how we are exceeding expectations, pretty much right where most people expected. The frustrating part is the close games we have lost with a dysfunctional lineup on the floor during crunch time. Get your best scorers on the floor the last 5-10 minutes of a game and ride them till they drop. We aren't Kentucky with a bench full of McDonalds All-Americans. Got to ride those that we know can play at this level. And maybe start a game with your best lineup so we don't have a slow start and have to fight back to get into the game.
I get tired of reading it, and I've said myself, but "the we were picked last and are exceeding expectations" line sounds like what a 4th grade teacher says to the fat kid who finishes last in the 50 yard dash. It should never be okay to be picked last, especially in a league as awful as this one is this year. We've seen the total collapse of Vegas and a much weaker than normal SDS team. We've lost a number of home games to less than stellar competition. Watching this team collapse in the second 1/2 of many games is heath schroyeresqe.
That said, I don't see how you can tell much about Edwards with this team. There really is'nt much there, talent wise. What disturbs me, however, is the team seems to be getting worse as the season progresses. Players that needed to develop, Naughton in particular, have basically been given up on.
Other players seem to have no discipline regarding shot selection or taking care of the ball. That's where I would expect coaching to play a prominent role.
Well said!!
Everyone wants to say that Shyatt inherited a real dumpster fire while Edwards is set up golden. I actually think Edwards is taking over with less (talent wise) than Shyatt did. Say what you want, Schroyer could recruit talent, he just couldnt coach to save his life. Edwards doesnt have a lot of great weapons outside of JJ and Adams (which, if memory serves, is an Edwards recruit, not Shyatt). Next season should be better as the recruits look to be improved compared to the last few years.
I disagree with this strongly (in terms of the respective programs they are taking over). I am going to get into the specific roster and why I think the roster Edwards inherited is significantly better than what Shyatt inherited, but even beyond that this was a better program to inherit:
1. Continuity - Edwards was already on staff, the players knew him and he only had to deal with replacing one senior and one departing player (Washington). The result is a much easier transition than going from a program in disarray that finished the season with an interim coach and had to fill 6 scholarships in the spring after being hired. That's almost half the roster.
2. Facilities - We all have some complaints about the way seating priority is handled in the AA, but the current setup with locker rooms, etc. is much better and a positive impact for recruiting.
3. Fan Support - Fan support sucks this year of course, but if you look at what Edwards is inheriting in terms of fan support from the last few years versus what Shyatt took over it is dramatically improved.
4. Perception - Pokes were last in the NCAA tournament in 2015. We have been a winning program recently. We have a recent grad (coached by Edwards when he was an assistant here) that was a first round draft pick and is doing well in the NBA. This is all much better than what Shyatt took over.
There are other concepts as well, including a general negative culture around the team, etc., but on balance the overall program outside of just the roster is in much better shape now than what Shyatt took over.
Now, on to the roster, let's take a closer look at exactly what was left for Shyatt:
Leonard Washington - Stud. However, someone with significant issues off court and in terms of team chemistry.
Luke Martinez - Luke was a pretty good player for the Pokes until his incident, but nobody was impressed that he was going to be part of the roster. He was a JUCO transfer/shooter that was lightly recruited out of Williston State. Luke's pedigree prior to that season was no better than Morris Marshall coming into this season.
Paco Cruz - Cruz had played the previous year as a key contributor on a team that went 3-13 in MWC play. Good shooter, decent mid range game, limited athletically. Nobody was impressed that he was coming back.
Adam Waddell - 5th year senior, Wyoming kid. Adam had a nice career, but by his senior season, injuries had sapped him of any jumping ability. He was one of the least effective rebounders at the 5 that you will ever see (post injury anyway, not true before), but was great at drawing charges.
Jaydee Luster - Tiny PG, couldn't really shoot. Under Shyatt he turned into a defensive pest/menace, but was definitely not held in high regard by the fan base prior to Shyatt's hire.
Arthur Bouedo - Remember him? No? There is a reason.
Afam Muojeke - Best returning player, only he couldn't really play due to the knee injury.
Watsabaugh was a returning walk-on as well and that was it. There were only 5 healthy D-1 players left (Bouedo wasn't a D-1 player and Muojeke was injured) and of those 5, only Leonard Washington would have been coveted by other MWC teams. Other than Leonard, we have a couple of regional JUCO transfer wings that were Big Sky recruits, a 5'6" PG that couldn't shoot, and a senior big man that couldn't really jump anymore.
Shyatt took over a team that had gone 6-28 against MWC opponents over the past 2 seasons. So take that roster, and then subtract 4 of the top 5 scorers (Jackson, MBaye, Thiam, and Muojeke because of the injury) and that is what you are left with. Yet, he went 6-8 in MWC play, 20-11 overall. Those numbers don't tell the full tale, because the MWC was stronger back then. That team finished 91st in KenPom's ratings and somewhere in the 80's in RPI if I recall correctly. That is incredible with that roster.
That team bought into Shyatt's philosophy on defense and significantly out performed their talent level.
Edwards inherited almost a full roster, one in which he helped recruit, that has an incredible talent in Justin James, a full stable of big men, none of who are stiffs (although they do lack in bulk for sure), and a group of perimeter shooters (Gorski/JMac).
I would take the current roster over the 11-12 roster every day. 11-12 was Shyatt's best coaching job. We can only hope that 16-17 is Edwards' worst.