LanderPoke said:Just noticed no Appleby. Should have been at least honorable mention
laxwyo said:It's hard to imagine any receiver better than Tanner
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
And the competition?joshvanklomp said:Important to look at stats from just conference games rather than including nonconference games.
Allen: 113-205, 1,882 yards, 17 TDs, 5 INTs
Rypien: 127-200, 2,038 yards, 16 TDs, 1 INT
Hill: 210 carries, 1,211 yards, 15 TDs
Pumphrey: 207 carries, 1,158 yards, 7 TDs
I think they made the right decision at both positions.
fromolwyoming said:And the competition?joshvanklomp said:Important to look at stats from just conference games rather than including nonconference games.
Allen: 113-205, 1,882 yards, 17 TDs, 5 INTs
Rypien: 127-200, 2,038 yards, 16 TDs, 1 INT
Hill: 210 carries, 1,211 yards, 15 TDs
Pumphrey: 207 carries, 1,158 yards, 7 TDs
I think they made the right decision at both positions.
Pumphery was held below 100 yards in both games against teams over .500 this season.
joshvanklomp said:Sorry, meant to put McNichols' stats instead of Pumphrey's. Not sure what I was thinking.
laxwyo said:You're not taking into account Josh's rushing stats. He had rushing tds and how many 3rd\4th down conversions
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Never said he did. In fact, I said the opposite.Wyo2dal said:joshvanklomp said:Sorry, meant to put McNichols' stats instead of Pumphrey's. Not sure what I was thinking.
Boise at least played a moderately solid schedule but McNichols definitely didn't deserve the nod over Hill
joshvanklomp said:I think they made the right decision at both positions.
joshvanklomp said:Never said he did. In fact, I said the opposite.Wyo2dal said:joshvanklomp said:Sorry, meant to put McNichols' stats instead of Pumphrey's. Not sure what I was thinking.
Boise at least played a moderately solid schedule but McNichols definitely didn't deserve the nod over Hill
joshvanklomp said:I think they made the right decision at both positions.
I'm confused. We both think Hill deserved first team over McNichols, so what exactly do we disagree about?Wyo2dal said:We just disagree which is fine everyone has an opinion and we're all entitled to them.
joshvanklomp said:I'm confused. We both think Hill deserved first team over McNichols, so what exactly do we disagree about?Wyo2dal said:We just disagree which is fine everyone has an opinion and we're all entitled to them.
Maybe you should include rush yards for the QBs? That is what separates them. Allen does more and is more valuablejoshvanklomp said:Important to look at stats from just conference games rather than including nonconference games.
Allen: 113-205, 1,882 yards, 17 TDs, 5 INTs
Rypien: 127-200, 2,038 yards, 16 TDs, 1 INT
Hill: 210 carries, 1,211 yards, 15 TDs
Pumphrey: 207 carries, 1,158 yards, 7 TDs
I think they made the right decision at both positions.