wyoav211933
Well-known member
Some of this won't surprise people, some of this won't. None of this is necessarily meant to demean any of our current players because we really do need them all, but maybe this might give us some perspective of how we evaluate a few of them.
The obvious-
Larry Nance is far and away our best player. He has the best defensive rating on our team (points allowed per 100 possesions) and it's honestly by a pretty large margin. He's in our top 3 on offensive rating too, but actually leads the team in offensive win shares, defensive win shares, win shares/40 min and PER (the last 3 of which nobody else on the team even comes close).
The surprising-
Derek Cooke is actually pretty darn important to our team too. In fact, you could make a pretty convincing argument with advanced stats that he is the 2nd or 3rd best player and more important than Nathan Sobey and Josh Adams. He is actually 3rd on the team in total win shares, a stat that actually should be lower for a guy that plays reduced minutes compared to the rest of the team. He is behind only Nance and Grabau, and when you consider win shares/40 min, he is actually second behind only Nance. Even though he's not what we'd consider a big scorer, what he does on offense contributes 120 points/100 possessions, which is actually 2nd on the team and ahead of even Nance.
What could make some people mad-
Josh Adams is a bit overrated. His true shooting percentage is pretty poor compared to the team, he has the lowest offensive rating of any regular not named Sobey, and his win shares/40 is damning, trailing guys like granberry and washington. This is unfortunate since he has close to the highest usage rate on the team.
Edit: The stat is win shares/40 minutes, not win shares/40 games. I believe I corrected it in all instances.
More to come if I have time.
The obvious-
Larry Nance is far and away our best player. He has the best defensive rating on our team (points allowed per 100 possesions) and it's honestly by a pretty large margin. He's in our top 3 on offensive rating too, but actually leads the team in offensive win shares, defensive win shares, win shares/40 min and PER (the last 3 of which nobody else on the team even comes close).
The surprising-
Derek Cooke is actually pretty darn important to our team too. In fact, you could make a pretty convincing argument with advanced stats that he is the 2nd or 3rd best player and more important than Nathan Sobey and Josh Adams. He is actually 3rd on the team in total win shares, a stat that actually should be lower for a guy that plays reduced minutes compared to the rest of the team. He is behind only Nance and Grabau, and when you consider win shares/40 min, he is actually second behind only Nance. Even though he's not what we'd consider a big scorer, what he does on offense contributes 120 points/100 possessions, which is actually 2nd on the team and ahead of even Nance.
What could make some people mad-
Josh Adams is a bit overrated. His true shooting percentage is pretty poor compared to the team, he has the lowest offensive rating of any regular not named Sobey, and his win shares/40 is damning, trailing guys like granberry and washington. This is unfortunate since he has close to the highest usage rate on the team.
Edit: The stat is win shares/40 minutes, not win shares/40 games. I believe I corrected it in all instances.
More to come if I have time.