The recruits in this class are better than the stars they've been given, IMO. Scout.com seems to have an affinity for bumping down everyone who commits to Wyoming by one star. It makes me mad, but then again, no matter how many stars they get, it doesn't change what they are in reality.
But just for the record, here are the players I would say are the 3-stars of this class (whether Rivals or Scout gives them 3 or not):
1.Tashaun Gipson -- CB from Dallas -- He's got speed, athleticism, size and the perfect support structure in place to become a star here. His brother, Marcel, already plays here, and he passed up offers from Baylor and Louisville to commit to the Pokes.
2. Orlando Arnold -- TE from Contra Costa CC -- Great athleticism but also great size. Great hands, experience, wonderful attitude, good grades, perhaps the all-around recruit and a terrific last-minute replacement for Wade Betschart.
3. James Caraway-- WR (tho he played RB in high school) from Topeka -- Blazing speed. Sub-4.35 40. The guy can flat-out move, and his highlight tape is ridiculous. Coaches want to get him the ball in a variety of ways. Could make an impact right away but definitely should be solid down the road. Terrific attitude. The only knock on him is his size--5-10, 170--but he should get a bit bigger here. He told me he thinks he can still get faster, too. Could also play CB if he has to and should be a great PR/KR.
4. Ben Parks -- Kicker from Argyle, Texas -- I know, I know, a kicker. But still, the guy's good. Scout ranks him as the 26th best kicker in the nation, and Wyoming pursued him even harder than a guy Chris Sailers ranked in the top 15 in the nation (Jordan Mannisto, who also had an offer from UW, which was basically used to pressure Parks into committing). Parks is a 3-star at his position, IMO. He also played LB in high school and had a whole bunch of tackles this year, so he's tough (6-foot-1, 188 pounds...not your average-sized kicker)...should help if anybody breaks one in kickoff situations.
5. Adam Barry-- Quarterback from Moorpark, Calif. -- Scout had him listed as a 3-star guy until he committed to Wyoming. Same with Parks. I think he'll redshirt this year and probably won't get much of a shot at playing until 2010, but he's got good fundamentals, a strong arm and is a smart kid. A lot of the analysts that saw him play in So Cal thought he was better than a lot of really highly-recruited kids down there (and there were a bunch of them).
6. Darin McDonald-- safety/wide receiver/cornerback from Cherry Creek HS in Colo. -- McDonald got drafted by the Phillies to play baseball right out of high school 2 years ago. He tried it for a while, and things didn't go quite the way he wanted, and now he's ready to try football. In the meantime, though, he added about 20 pounds of a muscle to a 6-foot-3 frame (now about 205 pounds). He used to run about a 4.48 40 (back in HS), but he told me on the phone that he thinks he's faster now. He had like 7 picks his senior year in high school. He could become a killer cover DB, but coaches are looking at him as a WR from what I hear. Either way, he's one of the few freshman who could come in right away and play this year. He's also another one with a terrific attitude. A friend of mine told me he saw him in the gymn up in Idaho over Christmas break and said he looked freakin' ripped.
7. Ben Durbin -- linebacker from Gilbert, Iowa. This is another one that had 3 stars until he committed to Wyoming. The guy is a freakin' tackling machine. He had more than 100 tackles and eight sacks as a junior and was named to the All-State team. As a senior, he had 143 tackles in just 9 games. He's super-excited about coming out to Wyoming. He committed way before his senior year even began (like back in July). Otherwise he probably would have landed a bunch of other offers. He was getting looked at by Kansas, Kansas State, Iowa, Iowa State and CSU. He's one of the gems of this class, IMO, and could very well have a Ward Dobbs-type career here.
There are others you could make an argument for (Kyle Magnuson, Dax Crum, David James, etc...), but those guys are the cream of the class, IMO. That's not to say that every one of them is going to come in and make an impact right away next year. I think guys like Barry and Durbin could use a redshirt to develop and learn the offense and defense, but they are terrific pick-ups for the future of the program.